Skip to content

Marketing Thought

Clarifying management/marketing theory

Menu
  • Neil Bendle
  • Popular Marketing Metrics: How Not To Mess Them Up
  • Marketing Metrics 4th Edition Book
  • Marketing PhD Applications
  • Advice For The Marketing Academic Job Market
  • Marketing Strategy
  • Public Policy, Behavioral Economics and Marketing
Menu

Managers and Academics

Posted on August 9, 2013November 26, 2021 by neilbendle

I think one the great rifts between managers and academics in marketing has been caused by NPS. To be fair there is blame on all sides.

Asking Questions

As researchers and teachers we have a responsibility to advance the practice of marketing. This isn’t just about teaching technical skills. Knowing how to discount a cash flow is useful. Maybe it is better to teach students to ask questions. Academics can often help students achieve this because they:

  • a) can step back from day to day pressures,
  • b) are, hopefully, trained in reasoning, and
  • c) are, if you are lucky, smart.

When a problem is raised and the answer evaded academics have a duty to help highlight the evasion. To illustrate let us turn to the Net Promoter Score. Because the claims were so strong for NPS it was perhaps inevitable that controversy would ensure. This is healthy, critics have a right to criticize and supporters to respond. Things can be said to defend NPS. The simplicity is potentially powerful, and the feedback systems interesting. What I do not think is okay is to avoid the question.

Trending
Defining Customer Experience And Its Role In Customer Journey

Serious Criticism Deserves A Response

Fred Reichheld says

They [critics] said they could find no connection between Net Promoter Scores and loyalty, growth or profits. … One senior executive who implemented NPS was barraged with e-mails protesting the plan to monitor NPS was simplistic –“based on flawed research, fragrantly illogical, statistically invalid and fundamentally flawed”.

Reichheld 2011 page 231

As I said critics have a right to criticize.

Reasonable Criticism Deserves A Proper Response
Reasonable Criticism Deserves A Proper Response

At this point, you might expect a response. An explanation of the connection between NPS and growth and evidence that the research wasn’t flawed. Instead, Reichheld seems to find calls to support his claims with evidence tedious. His thinking seems to be that because managers use the process it must be good. Sadly this was the same logic supporting punishing people for being left-handed and burning witches. People did those for generations but they really weren’t a very good idea. The lack of burning witches in your high street is why asking for evidence of causation is a good thing.

Managers And Academics Can Work Together

Asking for proper evidence is not just academic pedantry. To ask for proof and have none forthcoming is worrying. CEOs should seek evidence supporting the claims they make and claims made to them. (My advice: if your CEO doesn’t believe in causation then next time you mess up just shout “witch” and blame it on someone else).

We are a long way off having a perfect causal model for business success but we should at least be trying to get there. When asked for evidence their plan is a good one a CEO should have a better answer than “because I say so”.

For more on NPS see here, here, and here.

Read: Fred Reichheld, 2011, The Ultimate Question 2.0: How Net Promoters Thrive In A Customer-Driven World, Harvard Business Review Press

Share on Social Media
twitter facebook linkedin reddit

  • Internal Measurement Of Brand Value
  • Regulation And Business Responsibility
  • Leadership, Power, And Morality
  • Gaining And Using Power

MASB’s Common Language Dictionary

Need a marketing definition? Use MASB’s Common Language Marketing Dictionary. Click for the MASB Common Language Marketing Dictionary

Pages in Marketing Thought

  • A Plea About Language Used In Marketing
  • Advice For The Marketing Academic Job Market
  • Behavioral Econ For Kids: The Cartoon Book
  • Data Visualization Advice
  • Machine Learning (ML) And Marketing: What Should You Know?
  • Marketing In The Movies
  • Marketing Metrics 4th Edition Book
    • Chapter of Marketing Metrics 4th Edition, Free Sample
  • Marketing PhD Applications
  • Marketing Strategy
    • Measuring Culture Is A Challenge, But Don’t Be Silly
    • Rationality And Marketing Strategy
    • Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning
    • Strategy And Evolutionary Thinking
  • Neil Bendle
  • Popular Marketing Metrics: How Not To Mess Them Up
    • Brand Valuation: Progress But Lots More Needed
    • Customer Equity: Nice Idea, Bit Of A Mess In Execution
    • How To Use, And Misuse, Customer Lifetime Value (CLV)
    • Is ROI The Most Abused Term In Marketing?
    • Market Share: Always An Indicator Never A Target
    • Marketing Accounts: A Better Way To Measure Marketing Performance
    • Measuring Competition With The Bendle Panda Index
    • Net Promoter Score: Sadly Not As Magical As Supporters Suggest
    • Profit Measurement: Choose Your Own Level Is Problematic
    • Tobin’s Q: Why Academics Should Listen To Managers
    • Total Q, A New Improved Tobin’s Q? Not By Much
    • Value Of A Like: Do Not Use For Budgeting
  • Public Policy, Behavioral Economics and Marketing
  • Recommended Books
©2022 Marketing Thought | Built using WordPress and Responsive Blogily theme by Superb
Go to mobile version