Rutherford and Knowles (2008) highlight the tensions between finance and marketing. Their book goes by the title of “Vulcans, Earthlings and Marketing ROI”. The central thesis being that finance people are steady and logical, Vulcan in Star Trek, while marketers exciting and emotional, Earthlings. What can they tell us about Spock and Kirk and Marketing?…
Author: neilbendle
A Set of Metrics
The Canadian Marketing Association (CMA) have produced a set of metrics to capture performance. I would like to improve the definitions. In addition, the set more coherently presented. (For example, why squish retention and acquisition together in the list below?) Still, it is an interesting view on what marketers think. CMA Task Force The process…
Competition, Marketing, and the Common Good
I really enjoyed Robert Frank’s The Darwin Economy. What can this tell us about competition, marketing, and the common good? No Cash On The Table Frank emphasizes that “No Cash is On the Table” (Frank 2011, page 35) and “Markets Don’t Ignore Profitable Opportunities for Long” (page 35). Traditional economic theory suggests all profitable opportunities…
Managers and Academics
I think one the great rifts between managers and academics in marketing has been caused by NPS. To be fair there is blame on all sides. Asking Questions As researchers and teachers we have a responsibility to advance the practice of marketing. This isn’t just about teaching technical skills. Knowing how to discount a cash…
Academics And Managers
The application of research is a big topic in marketing and academics and managers would be well served by acting together more. Is Useful Important? We debate whether we are useful or relevant. And then we debate whether we should care about whether we are useful or relevant. I think of myself as an academic…
Storytelling: Not An Insult. But You Need Cogent Stories
Critics often label evolutionary psychology “just so stories”– fanciful storytelling. This has become a popular criticism. “Just so stories” is a fantastic phrase. It is so evocative and damning. Serious scholars even use it to justify not reading evolutionary psychology. The critics sometimes have a point. I agree that some research relies on dubious arguments….
Big Questions
One of my favorite popular science books is Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs and Steel. Some didn’t appreciate it as much yet it does a fantastic job of asking big questions. These are the questions most worth asking. The Importance Of Geography Guns, Germs, and Steel is packed with fascinating details, has a great tempo, and…
Who Owns The Numbers?
Numbers are vital to running any organization but who owns the numbers? Measurement And Judgment Pfeffer and Sutton’s (2000) book chapter starts a bit too negatively for my liking. The title sets the wrong tone. “When Measurement Obstructs Good Judgement”. To be fair their point isn’t that measurement is bad. They really mean that bad…
Good And Bad Profits
Fred Reichheld is best known for his (over) exuberant advocacy of the Net Promoter Score. Introducing Net Promoter he suggests a difference between good and bad profits; an interesting, though theoretically imprecise, idea. Are All Dollars In The Same? Short of outright fraud, isn’t one dollar of earnings as good as another? Certainly, accountants can’t…
Marketing State Of Mind
Marketers often brag about understanding external customers. They often do this while ignoring internal customers. To be a great marketer understanding the end consumer isn’t enough. Having a “marketing state of mind” means trying to solve the problems of your internal customers. Why is that? Internal Customers Of Marketers Imagine a simplified firm: the accountants…