In 2024 Shelly Rathee and Tyler Milfield investigated what we know about sustainable advertising. They looked at what makes advertising sustainable and reviewed the nature of sustainability for the readers of the International Journal of Advertising.
What We Know About Sustainable Advertising
The paper helpfully classifies sustainable advertising. Much of this will be familiar to anyone who knows about advertising. The macro-environment matters as does culture, source characteristics and execution. Things that are perhaps a little more salient in sustainable advertising (compared to all advertising) is the role of crises. The authors see a need for future research that tackles how companies are responding to global and local crises. When facing rising temperatures and wildfires what should a company do? If you are a better form of company is it appropriate to advertise invoking natural disasters as context? Does it seem tasteless? If during a crisis it is “too soon” to highlight the actions the company took to alleviate the problems then when is okay?
Sustainable Advertising Effectiveness
Like any type of advertising it is important to try and understand whether sustainable advertising was effective. There is work done on assessing ad effectiveness but, as ever, more would be useful.
…research on ad effectiveness measures should expand beyond attitudinal measures to behavioral choices in order to include real-world field studies. Potential research includes (a) considering how a consumer’s actual (versus reported) knowledge of sustainability affects ad response; (b) investigating implicit attitudes, particularly given the known effects of social desirability bias; and (c) using social media metrics (likes, number of followers, views, sentiment analysis).
Rathee and Milfield, 20024, page 23
We are all aware that sometimes people answer questions with the intention of making themselves look good, rather than being totally honest. Perhaps even being honest with themselves. Still, there is a lot of room to improve our understanding of when the size of such bias is likely to be especially large. What also can be done to help consumers do the good things that they aspire to do but don’t currently get round to doing?
Greenwashing And Social Washing
The authors also note the problems around greenwashing (claiming to be better for the environment than the brand is) and social washing (claiming to be better for society than the brand is). One challenge I think that is particularly hard to address is the problem of scale. Assume a claim by a firm is true, the action was positive, but the impact was relative modest. How much of a duty does a firm have to let the public know their (honestly reported) actions won’t make a massive impact on the problem. How sophisticated should we expect the public to be in appreciating without being told that a medium sized firm is only going to make a modest impact on massive global problems?
Values come into place here. Maybe the impact is large but in a niche area, e.g., saving a species of amphibian. You may honestly think this was really important and so you might see the action as highly consequential. Others may not think the area as crucial when you advertise the achievement. Is this greenwashing? Understanding sustainable advertising can be a real challenge.

For more on advertising see The Long-Term Impact Of Advertising, Advertising Budgeting And Managerially Relevant Research, Should Firms Advertise Their Good Deeds? and TV Still Matters For Advertising
Read: Shelly Rathee and Tyler Milfield (2024) Sustainability advertising: literature review and framework for future research, International Journal of Advertising, 43(1), pages 7-35
