Philip Tetlock’s book on expert political judgment was a classic but he clearly thinks that the message taken from that book was too strong. Previously he suggested that experts just aren’t that good at forecasting. He still retains that theme in his new work — he talks about how expert forecasts are vague and so unfalsifiable. “Fuzzy thinking can never be proved wrong” (Tetlock and Gardner, 2015, page 252).
That said he is now focusing on how we get better at forecasting. The good news is that he thinks that we can improve. We might never be perfect but we can nudge forward. He talks about why forecasts often don’t improve: “The consumers of forecasting — governments, business, and the public — don’t demand evidence of accuracy” (Tetlock and Gardner, 2015, page 14). He thinks too much forecasting is about sounding good rather than developing testable predictions. Never testing and finding your mistakes means you can never learn from them.
He suggests one way to improve forecasting is to break the problem down into easier to understand parts. I think his ideas apply to a lot of work in metrics. Expressing something clearly allows you a chance to be visibly wrong and so improve. This is vastly superior to vague nonsense. I agree with Tetlock: “… don’t suppose that because a scoring system needs tweaking it isn’t a big improvement” (Tetlock and Gardner, 2015, page 261).
His advice is clear and widely applicable. “Flush ignorance into the open. Expose and examine your assumptions. Dare to be wrong by making your best guesses. Better to discover errors quickly than to hide them behind vague verbiage” (Tetlock and Gardner, 2015, page 278).
There is a lot that can be learned from listening to Tetlock. I’ll predict that the world will be a better place if we pay attention to the advice he shares. Sadly this isn’t really a testable prediction given “better place” is a little vague but hopefully you get my point.
Read: Philip E. Tetlock and Dan Gardner (2015) Superforecasting: The Art and Science of Prediction, McClelland and Stewart.